I've been calling 'CAPS' 'CRAPS' for a while now, on the basis that it's well, pretty crappy. But it occurs to me that its pretty apt in another way too. It's basically a roll of the dice. Maybe - if we're lucky - some folk in Scotland will start cycling, but maybe not. Either way, we're not going to do much to tilt the odds one way or the other.
So the CRAPS refresh today, instead of accepting that with the current policy they will not meet any of their targets, redefines it to a 'vision' and blindly carries on with the same old failed policies.
Apparently, the national government can't actually allocate money to specific cycling projects, because that would be trampling on local authorities autonomy. Oddly, that doesn't affect their decision to fund roads or 'car projects' to the tune of billions.
Specifically, they can spend £6bn on two road dualling projects with no evidence that this would make the roads safer, but not find even a fraction of that for cyclepaths, which are proven to reduce injury and encourage more cyclists. As a wiser head than mine says:
"It's not that there's no money, it's just that the Scottish Government chooses to spend it on roads."
It's CRAP(S). and we need to call it that.
19 June 2013
15 June 2013
We've got a long way to go...
When did you last see kids riding bikes on the street with their parents?
I suspect the answer is 'not recently' or 'not often' and that if you did, you probably saw me and my kids, or one of the three other families that I know that let their kids ride on the road.
I was reading this short article Cycling Kids: The True Indicator of a Bike-Friendly City and it reminded me how far we have to go. It suggests that “When kids feel confident enough to ride on their own — and parents let them — then your city has truly earned the ‘bike-friendly’ label.” Yup. But before we get to that, we need to pass an even earlier stage: When parents ride on the road with their kids... then your city is heading towards that ‘bike-friendly’ label.
I'm seeing a lot more childseats and trailers around town. (And more female cyclists) So, maybe we're heading in the right direction. But we've got a long way to go yet.
That said, there's lots of fun family events on at the Festival of Cycling this weekend.. Let's just hope the families attending don't all drive there with bikes strapped onto their cars...
I suspect the answer is 'not recently' or 'not often' and that if you did, you probably saw me and my kids, or one of the three other families that I know that let their kids ride on the road.
I was reading this short article Cycling Kids: The True Indicator of a Bike-Friendly City and it reminded me how far we have to go. It suggests that “When kids feel confident enough to ride on their own — and parents let them — then your city has truly earned the ‘bike-friendly’ label.” Yup. But before we get to that, we need to pass an even earlier stage: When parents ride on the road with their kids... then your city is heading towards that ‘bike-friendly’ label.
I'm seeing a lot more childseats and trailers around town. (And more female cyclists) So, maybe we're heading in the right direction. But we've got a long way to go yet.
That said, there's lots of fun family events on at the Festival of Cycling this weekend.. Let's just hope the families attending don't all drive there with bikes strapped onto their cars...
13 June 2013
The bins (part 2): is this what a victory feels like?
It's been a depressing day in a depressing week. This was symbolised today by people congratulating me on my 'victory' and getting a 'result'. That result can be seen here:
Missed it? It's that little white line around the bins, that seems to be magically keeping them in place. It's the result of several weeks persistent lobbying. Earlier in the week, it has looked like this:
As chronicled in more detail in a previous post, this was an on-going quest, actually started by someone else, to remove the recycling bins from the sight-lines of a pedestrian crossing in front of a primary school.
But have we really fallen so low in the stakes of civic activism that a little white paint around some bins (with promise of a more permanent corral when the pavement is redone), is counted a victory?
It doesn't feel much like one.
07 June 2013
Why is there no 'autotrans'?
There's something I don't understand about transport funding in the UK. Why is it that active travel funds have to be 'bid for' from funds held elsewhere? Why don't they just get budgeted for like other infrastructure? I mean, we don't hear about plans to dual a motorway being contingent on the outcome of a bid to 'autotrans'? or the improvement of local roads being cancelled because of an unsuccessful bids, do we? (or have I missed the fine print?)
This has been puzzling me for a while, but became particularly pertinent today, with the very welcome news that the City of Edinburgh listened to our concerns about their previous proposals for Leith Walk, and have now put forward a revised set of proposals. The new 'enhanced' designs respond to many concerns from local residents, workers and shoppers. But they depend on a successful bid for national money, which we're now being asked to lobby the Scottish Government for.
Somehow, the Council happened to have exactly the right amount stashed away to improve Leith Walk, as long as it only involved existing tarmac and pavement configurations. But add in 'bike lanes' and it's a whole new ball game and entirely impossible to do without 'securing outside funding'.
I do appreciate that the councils funds are limited, and I would very much like the Scottish government to fully back initiatives like this, because they will save them money many times over in health, environment and business income.
But, I still don't understand why projects like this are treated like they're optional extras, or somehow less important than 'normal' road building.
Can anyone explain?
This has been puzzling me for a while, but became particularly pertinent today, with the very welcome news that the City of Edinburgh listened to our concerns about their previous proposals for Leith Walk, and have now put forward a revised set of proposals. The new 'enhanced' designs respond to many concerns from local residents, workers and shoppers. But they depend on a successful bid for national money, which we're now being asked to lobby the Scottish Government for.
Somehow, the Council happened to have exactly the right amount stashed away to improve Leith Walk, as long as it only involved existing tarmac and pavement configurations. But add in 'bike lanes' and it's a whole new ball game and entirely impossible to do without 'securing outside funding'.
I do appreciate that the councils funds are limited, and I would very much like the Scottish government to fully back initiatives like this, because they will save them money many times over in health, environment and business income.
But, I still don't understand why projects like this are treated like they're optional extras, or somehow less important than 'normal' road building.
Can anyone explain?
04 June 2013
Is this the worst intersection in Edinburgh?
View Larger Map
I've blogged about this intersection before, but hearing today that it's not going to be resurfaced for at least another year has driven me to it again.
![]() |
| King's Junction courtesy of Andy Arthur |
It doesn't help that cars waiting in the turn lane opposite regularly gamble on slow starts and nip across, even though vehicles coming from Tarvit street onto Gilmore Place have priority. But anyone who rides or drives it frequently knows that their light is short and that only the first 2 or 3 cars will make it across, so they feel pressured to bully their way through. And, if you are lucky enough to approach the light while it is green and make it through, inevitably a pededstrian walks out in front of you. One day I hit the jackpot and had pedestrians wander out on the west side of the intersection AND on the east side as I tried to navigate my way through.
But it's not just that direction that is dodgy. Coming along Gilmore Place you know it's going to be a bad intersection because of the ferocity with which other drivers overtake you, just so that they can reach the red lights first.
You can't go straight-ahead, so the road divides into two lanes: a left turn lane that gets an advance green and a right turn lane that has to wait for oncoming traffic. (Except that usually it doesn't.) The left turn lane is also usually splayed out into the putative right turn lane because of badly parked cars and a bus stop, as you can see here.
View Larger Map
If you're in the right turn lane, as I usually am, you then have to decide whether you want to be in the ASZ or not (assuming there's not a car or a number 27 bus in it). I usually do sit in it, unless there's a queue of cars. But a lot of experienced cyclists I know avoid it, because vehicles turning left from Home St tend to clip the ASZ. Steel-capped boots recommended.
The intersection's not too bad if you approach from Leven Street or Home Street but fast and busy with too many lanes. If you try to come down Home St and turn left onto Gilmore Place in the evening, the pedestrian gamble hits you again - they're usually trying to catch a bus.
On the other hand, if you are trying to come from Tollcross and turn onto Gilmore Place, you have to do one of those fun fast lane changes, usually surrounded by buses and taxis. But let's face it, if you cycled through Tollcross to get there, you're probably tough enough to handle it.
Thing is -- this is one of the city's main commuter routes. It's part of NCN75. It ought to be a nice route to do some shopping in Realfoods, Provenance wines, and Lupe Pintos, to name only my favourites. But it's horrendous, and anyone in their right mind avoids it.
Plans are afoot to provide a safer, more family-friendly access from the Canal to the Meadows. I'm hoping to get some insight into what that will look like soon. But a good proportion of the city's cyclists will still be heading through here most days. Surely we can come up with some way of improving it?
03 June 2013
Credit where credit is due
![]() | ||
| NMW thanks to chdot on flickr |
But the real reason I'm mentioning it, is that the western 'spur' that led to the toucan crossing of Melville Drive, was supposed to remain quite narrow and awkward. But enough feedback was sent, and although we were first told that nothing could be done, then as work started, we were told that it would be widened. The reason we raised this was because that spur had real potential to push cyclists and pedestrians into unnecessary conflict. And we didn't want that.
But the reason I'm mentioning this now (when I should be washing dishes), is that in this case, the consultation actually listened to users, and accommodated them. I'm pretty sure the end result will be a great improvement for the many commuters, joggers, dog-walkers etc, and for Meadows as well - surely one of Edinburgh's greatest resources.
Well done CEC and everyone who contributed to the decision. Let's have more of this - all over the city.
A letter to my councillors part 2
More on Princes Street (part 1 here: http://www.deceasedcanine.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/a-letter-to-my-councillors.html)
I'm less and less sure that there's really any point to this. Even if they do change the proposal tomorrow, it should never have gotten to this point. All that will result is that the council will be pilloried for caving in to the 'cycle lobby'. When really they should have got it right at the proposal stage, consulted properly, and then brought an idea that all users could enthusiastically back to the full council vote. Transport committee (apologies for original incorrect point here - I need more sleep)
Anyway, here's the letter for what it's worth:
It is very disappointing to note that Transport Committee is proposing to go ahead with its original proposal, albeit for a 12 month trial. Surely, if this is really a 'trial' it would make sense to also trial a west-east cycle route? Then, if it proves unworkable or unsafe, this will be clear in planning for the permanent changes?
There are three other points that I hope you will consider:
1. The consultation survey was flawed. In particular it asked if people approved of a 'one-way system for buses and taxis' but did not mention that cycles would also be included within it. It is therefore difficult to understand how the transport committee reached its decision - it does not appear to be on the basis of 'evidence'.
2. Princes St is designated as a 'core path' which permits access for cycles and pedestrians. It surely goes against the intent of the core path network to make this one-way only (it might indeed be illegal).
3. This further highlights the point I have made to you previously, that it is council policy to provide a cycle-contra-flow lane on one-way streets.
The proposed plans thus seem to fly in the face of both Core Path legislation and the council's own ATAP. Surely in the light of all this, it makes more sense to have a bi-directional cycle path along princes street? Or a cycle-path along the north side to allow easy access to shops?
As a member of the Transport Forum and the Cycle Forum, I have hoped that the council really does take its commitment to Active Travel seriously - I hope that my faith in you on this point is upheld by your decision tomorrow.
I'm less and less sure that there's really any point to this. Even if they do change the proposal tomorrow, it should never have gotten to this point. All that will result is that the council will be pilloried for caving in to the 'cycle lobby'. When really they should have got it right at the proposal stage, consulted properly, and then brought an idea that all users could enthusiastically back to the
Anyway, here's the letter for what it's worth:
It is very disappointing to note that Transport Committee is proposing to go ahead with its original proposal, albeit for a 12 month trial. Surely, if this is really a 'trial' it would make sense to also trial a west-east cycle route? Then, if it proves unworkable or unsafe, this will be clear in planning for the permanent changes?
There are three other points that I hope you will consider:
1. The consultation survey was flawed. In particular it asked if people approved of a 'one-way system for buses and taxis' but did not mention that cycles would also be included within it. It is therefore difficult to understand how the transport committee reached its decision - it does not appear to be on the basis of 'evidence'.
2. Princes St is designated as a 'core path' which permits access for cycles and pedestrians. It surely goes against the intent of the core path network to make this one-way only (it might indeed be illegal).
3. This further highlights the point I have made to you previously, that it is council policy to provide a cycle-contra-flow lane on one-way streets.
The proposed plans thus seem to fly in the face of both Core Path legislation and the council's own ATAP. Surely in the light of all this, it makes more sense to have a bi-directional cycle path along princes street? Or a cycle-path along the north side to allow easy access to shops?
As a member of the Transport Forum and the Cycle Forum, I have hoped that the council really does take its commitment to Active Travel seriously - I hope that my faith in you on this point is upheld by your decision tomorrow.
30 May 2013
Elite sport or a more active community?
Felt I had to write one last letter to my Councillors:
One last comment before your meeting today - my comments on Waterworld are pretty much summed up here
http://deceasedcanine. blogspot.co.uk/2013/05/the- sad-lessons-of-waterworld.html
But can I also add, that as a cyclist, I am appalled that you are spending £1m on the cycletrack proposed for Jack Kane/Hunter's Hall, and not on Waterworld? It is entirely unclear that there is any case to be made for the Jack Kane/Hunter Hall track - and many concerns about it. It will only ever be used by a tiny minority of elite cyclists - and the best of them will go to Glasgow for the velodrome anyway. But Waterworld would support kids starting out on healthier, active lifestyles -- especially groups in the city who may not use other sports facilities. Softplay does not fill this gap, and the market is already over saturated in Edinburgh anyway.
Both Waterworld/Commie pool and the Meadowbank/Jack Kane sagas capture Edinburgh's problem - not maintaining or marketing facilities that we have, and then promoting elite sport over fun activities that channel kids into more active lifestyles.
We're all aware of the financial challenges faced by the city, but they are the result of short term thinking and will only be solved by more long-term planning, not just plugging holes.
One last comment before your meeting today - my comments on Waterworld are pretty much summed up here
http://deceasedcanine.
But can I also add, that as a cyclist, I am appalled that you are spending £1m on the cycletrack proposed for Jack Kane/Hunter's Hall, and not on Waterworld? It is entirely unclear that there is any case to be made for the Jack Kane/Hunter Hall track - and many concerns about it. It will only ever be used by a tiny minority of elite cyclists - and the best of them will go to Glasgow for the velodrome anyway. But Waterworld would support kids starting out on healthier, active lifestyles -- especially groups in the city who may not use other sports facilities. Softplay does not fill this gap, and the market is already over saturated in Edinburgh anyway.
Both Waterworld/Commie pool and the Meadowbank/Jack Kane sagas capture Edinburgh's problem - not maintaining or marketing facilities that we have, and then promoting elite sport over fun activities that channel kids into more active lifestyles.
We're all aware of the financial challenges faced by the city, but they are the result of short term thinking and will only be solved by more long-term planning, not just plugging holes.
29 May 2013
The sad lessons of Waterworld
| Fyrishof in Uppsala - now that's a swimming pool! |
So when we heard in January that the Council would consider - support even - a community bid to reopen Waterworld, we were delighted. It seemed like finally, things were being done differently. Which is why we all feel like we've been kicked in the guts today. The council is going to vote tomorrow, but both parties in the ruling coalition support selling Waterworld for a derisory £1million so that a profitmaking firm can turn it into softplay. There are already several softplays in Leith, and certainly no one is going to travel down Leith walk just to go to another one. So this one will just take business away from the existing operations. I can't see any long-term financial logic, nor benefit to the council accepting the commercial offer. The only justification seems to be that 'council officials recommended it'.
The comments on Andrew Burns blog are a must read. Passionate pleading for a pool that is warm, and shallow enough for toddlers. The sloping 'beach' like entrance. The waves and slide. The Commonwealth pool does have a small pool for kids, but it's regularly too full and people are turned away. A pool where they can play with their kids, not watch them from the side. They put it so much better than I can. Do read them.
It's ridiculous that people are driving their kids to Dunbar and Perth so that they can play in fun pools, but it's even more devastating to have the council pull the rug out from under the feet of people who have been working hard to set up the bid.
This decision has absolutely shattered the trust and faith of community activists, many of them just local families trying to work with the council to improve their local area. For many this will have been their first taste of activism and engagement. What message have they been sent? That the council doesn't care about them. That their elected representatives can't be trusted. That's going to be the long term legacy of this decision. And that's even sadder than all the kids who will not know the fun of playing in warm water with their parents and learn to love water and sport.
23 May 2013
Why I can't see past the obstacles to being strategic
A local politician keeps telling me to 'think strategic' and 'not bother him (and others) with the little stuff'. He means well, but day after day I see little stuff that drives me crazy.
I can't help but think that if we didn't have to spend so much time on the little stuff, maybe we could actually find time to think strategically? But that means getting stuff right the first time, and joining up the various policies.
A few weeks ago, the administrator of CCE and I had a meeting with a council official about some inadequate bike infrastructure near my kids school (more about that later). He also pointed out that the sightlines on one of the crossings in front of the school are obstructed by recycling bins - as you can see in the picture.
We were assured it would be looked at and dealt with. But a few weeks later, it looked like this:
And then like this:
And then today like this:
Each time I've noticed this and taken pictures, I've tweeted the relevant authorities and been assured it is being dealt with.
Reporting faults by twitter is pretty easy, and not that time-consuming. But as long as very simple policies like 'not obstructing pedestrians sightlines' at crossings can't be managed, how exactly are we supposed to think strategically and focus on the big picture?
I'm not posting this to beat up on the folks who have been responding to my tweets, but to make the point that the best policies -- whether tenement recycling schemes or safer travel for schoolkids -- are only as good as their implementation and maintenance.
21 May 2013
What's so different about cycling?
My kids seem to do pretty much everything in school - someone teaches them swimming, dancing, tennis, plus normal PE.
But, when it comes to learning how to ride a bike, although there is a prescribed curriculum, and a commitment from the council to ensuring that it is delivered to all P6s, it all depends on parent volunteers.
Why?
Cycling isn't just a sport. It's also life-skill. It will help them get to their sports practices, their summer jobs, and to lectures at uni. It helps us remain healthier as individuals and as a population. It keeps our environment in better shape, and reduces congestion on the roads.
But it's not important enough for schools to actually pay trained professionals to deliver this training to our kids. I'm sure the volunteers are great, but it also means very uneven implementation - and that's before we even get to the schools that ban kids from riding their bikes to school so that they can learn how to ride their bikes....
So why is cycling the one sport/activity (as far as I can tell) that schools are expected to deliver in class time, but through volunteers?
But, when it comes to learning how to ride a bike, although there is a prescribed curriculum, and a commitment from the council to ensuring that it is delivered to all P6s, it all depends on parent volunteers.
Why?
Cycling isn't just a sport. It's also life-skill. It will help them get to their sports practices, their summer jobs, and to lectures at uni. It helps us remain healthier as individuals and as a population. It keeps our environment in better shape, and reduces congestion on the roads.
But it's not important enough for schools to actually pay trained professionals to deliver this training to our kids. I'm sure the volunteers are great, but it also means very uneven implementation - and that's before we even get to the schools that ban kids from riding their bikes to school so that they can learn how to ride their bikes....
So why is cycling the one sport/activity (as far as I can tell) that schools are expected to deliver in class time, but through volunteers?
We're not #bloodycyclists, We're everyone
If one message came out of this year's Pedal on Parliament, it's that we're not 'cyclists', we're everyone. The wonderful Sally Hinchcliffe put this down in words and it was picked up by the Herald, and Scotsman.
We often say that cycling infrastructure needs to be for everyone from 8-80 and on Sunday friends of mine from many different walks of life - work, sunday school, pub mates - were there ranging in age from babes in arms to octogenarians (My friend Bill is desperate to know if he was the oldest again :)
Right now, on twitter there's a campaign to reclaim the hashtag #bloodycyclists. As @citycyclists said "Let's get 'I'm one of the#bloodycyclists" trending? I bike. I don't want to be bloody because some idiot doesn't like my transport choice" This is in response to the dangerous and very foolish young driver in Norfolk, who knocked a cyclist into a hedge, lost her side mirror, and kept going only to tweet about it.
Yes. the double meaning makes it extra powerful. And some of the testimonies are very powerful. Like others, I too have been a #bloodycyclist. And I'm terrified my kids will be too.
But I'm not just a #bloody cyclist. I'm also a mum, a teacher, a member of our parish church, and most importantly a voter.
We're not #bloodycyclists. We're everyone.
| This is the start of our 140+ feeder ride to the main Pedal on Parliament |
We often say that cycling infrastructure needs to be for everyone from 8-80 and on Sunday friends of mine from many different walks of life - work, sunday school, pub mates - were there ranging in age from babes in arms to octogenarians (My friend Bill is desperate to know if he was the oldest again :)
Right now, on twitter there's a campaign to reclaim the hashtag #bloodycyclists. As @citycyclists said "Let's get 'I'm one of the
Yes. the double meaning makes it extra powerful. And some of the testimonies are very powerful. Like others, I too have been a #bloodycyclist. And I'm terrified my kids will be too.
But I'm not just a #bloody cyclist. I'm also a mum, a teacher, a member of our parish church, and most importantly a voter.
We're not #bloodycyclists. We're everyone.
16 May 2013
Why we need to Pedal on Parliament
All of the route - except the little section that you can see here -is off-road. But that little section between two wonderful family-friendly routes includes one of Edinburgh's least cycle friendly intersections.
Last year we had some nice policemen come along and stop traffic for us. Which was great, except that apparently this year, they won't do that. So, we're stressing and kind of hoping we won't have 120 cyclists like we did last year. Cause it will take us ages to cross at that rate, even if we all dash across on the green man. But the bigger issue is that most days, we all have to negotiate dodgy intersections like this one.
This illustrates why Pedal on Parliament is so essential - it is ridiculous that families with kids don't feel safe cycling between the canal and the meadows. How can we expect them to go anywhere in the city if they can't do that? The good news is that the City of Edinburgh recognizes this problem, and it is near the top of planned infrastructural improvements as part of their Active Travel Action Plan.
But this is only going to actually be implemented because the Council is committing 6% of its transport budget to Active Travel, with a planned increase of 1% each year until they reach 10%.
Edinburgh is one of the only municipalities to spend this high a proportion of its budget on cycling. But the effects are clear - in increased numbers of cyclists every year. This shows what can happen if the Scottish Government also commits itself to a target of 5% of the budget for cycling and 10% for Active travel, as we call for in our manifesto.
But we need to get to the Meadows first in order to ask them to do so - any volunteers to ride with us? https://www.facebook.com/events/150599691787564/
10 May 2013
The H-word
How many of us wear helmets so that when we get squashed the judge can't say it was our fault? I know I'm not alone in doing this.
But as I wrote a letter to the procurator fiscal (you can too) about the leniency shown in the sentencing for Gary McCourt for the death of Audrey Fyfe, I found myself even less able than normal to justify this position. And for several days this week I have left my helmet at home.
I don't need (nor want) to read any more studies or studies about the health benefits/disbenefits of helmets. I've not changed my mind on that. But I am angry that the judge had the temerity to claim that her not wearing a helmet contributed to her death, when there is absolutely no evidence to back that up. The only person responsible for Audrey Fyfe's death is the man who was in charge of the powerful machine that hit her bicycle. And we need a legal system that acknowledges this, and holds careless and dangerous drivers responsible for their actions.
So, for the moment, I am helmet-less. I will probably revert -- especially in the dark winter when even my short commute feels perilous -- but right now, this is my small gesture in support of Audrey Fyfe. I only hope I'm still cycling when I'm 75.
But as I wrote a letter to the procurator fiscal (you can too) about the leniency shown in the sentencing for Gary McCourt for the death of Audrey Fyfe, I found myself even less able than normal to justify this position. And for several days this week I have left my helmet at home.
I don't need (nor want) to read any more studies or studies about the health benefits/disbenefits of helmets. I've not changed my mind on that. But I am angry that the judge had the temerity to claim that her not wearing a helmet contributed to her death, when there is absolutely no evidence to back that up. The only person responsible for Audrey Fyfe's death is the man who was in charge of the powerful machine that hit her bicycle. And we need a legal system that acknowledges this, and holds careless and dangerous drivers responsible for their actions.
So, for the moment, I am helmet-less. I will probably revert -- especially in the dark winter when even my short commute feels perilous -- but right now, this is my small gesture in support of Audrey Fyfe. I only hope I'm still cycling when I'm 75.
14 April 2013
Good for business?
There's a lot of data around these days pointing out that cycling is good for business and that cycle-lanes drive up footfall etc
But I've been struck by how many new cycle-related businesses have started up in the past two years or so
My attempt to itemize them (much helped by this useful site) came up with:
3 new tour companies: Storybikes, Tartan bike tours and Edinburgh Bike Rides
Loads of new repair shops: The Bike Garage, the Bike Smith Harts Pedals & Greasemonkey,
Bike sales: A couple of big national players -- Evans and Decathlon -- have opened up and although the Bike Chain has sadly closed, the Bike co-op is keeping the shop open as a second Edinburgh branch. There seem to be fewer new, independent retailers, but considering that we have a total of 14 already, perhaps that's not so surprising. One exception might be the redoubtable Laidback bikes, which has now got a 'proper' shopfront in Marchmont. There is also a new second-hand dealer: Soulcycles. Their website's a bit primitive, but like a lot of the newer shops, they're using facebook quite effectively to promote themselves.
Even one cafe: Ronde and two pubs: Ventoux and Tourmalet....
Couldn't some enterprising researcher or journalist work out their contribution to the local economy, jobs, etc and quantify it for us?
But I've been struck by how many new cycle-related businesses have started up in the past two years or so
My attempt to itemize them (much helped by this useful site) came up with:
3 new tour companies: Storybikes, Tartan bike tours and Edinburgh Bike Rides
Loads of new repair shops: The Bike Garage, the Bike Smith Harts Pedals & Greasemonkey,
Bike sales: A couple of big national players -- Evans and Decathlon -- have opened up and although the Bike Chain has sadly closed, the Bike co-op is keeping the shop open as a second Edinburgh branch. There seem to be fewer new, independent retailers, but considering that we have a total of 14 already, perhaps that's not so surprising. One exception might be the redoubtable Laidback bikes, which has now got a 'proper' shopfront in Marchmont. There is also a new second-hand dealer: Soulcycles. Their website's a bit primitive, but like a lot of the newer shops, they're using facebook quite effectively to promote themselves.
Even one cafe: Ronde and two pubs: Ventoux and Tourmalet....
Couldn't some enterprising researcher or journalist work out their contribution to the local economy, jobs, etc and quantify it for us?
Parent solidarity needed?
On Friday, I wrote two posts about cars/driving/traffic near my daughter's primary school. Well worn territory for me, unfortunately (see 'school run' labels). That same day, the Guardian ran a piece about getting kids to school on bikes.
All this fed into a couple of discussions on CityCyclingEdinburgh - one about a school which had 'banned' kids from riding to school and another one where a lot of money has gone into building a turning circle in front of the school, apparently to facilitate car-based drop-offs. But we also know of schools in the vicinity with really enthusiastic programmes supporting cycling and walking to school. And in other places, the police and traffic wardens are supporting various initiatives - like adding double yellows to zigzags and banning cars from 300m from school entrances.
This unevenness leads to the ridiculousness of kids being told in writing that they have to push their bikes to school, while just down the road, the Head Teacher at my school - despite being personally supportive - says that she can't do anything 'beyond her gate' i.e. all the parents who stop on the zig-zags and 'keep clears' and double-park in the road to drop off their kids.
But it's not just that these policies are random and incoherent, and that enforcement varies greatly, but also that groups of parents feel isolated and uncertain of what their rights are, or what other schools are doing to change things.
There seems to be some momentum for a city-wide meeting of parents to discuss how different schools deal with such issues and what lessons can be garnered. I'd also like to have some representation from Council, either from the road safety or active travel teams, as they have a lot of knowledge and experience.
There's a couple of different issues bundled in here - encouraging more kids/parents to use active travel to get to school where appropriate but also making the streets around schools safer in general. We all know how quieter and safer the streets feel when the schools are on holiday, but it shouldn't be like that. I'd like to see them safer when the kids are on them, not when they're at home or in the park playing!
If you'd be interested in getting involved, or just attending a meeting to share ideas, please get in touch via comments, twitter, or email.
![]() |
| Nursery run! |
This unevenness leads to the ridiculousness of kids being told in writing that they have to push their bikes to school, while just down the road, the Head Teacher at my school - despite being personally supportive - says that she can't do anything 'beyond her gate' i.e. all the parents who stop on the zig-zags and 'keep clears' and double-park in the road to drop off their kids.
But it's not just that these policies are random and incoherent, and that enforcement varies greatly, but also that groups of parents feel isolated and uncertain of what their rights are, or what other schools are doing to change things.
There seems to be some momentum for a city-wide meeting of parents to discuss how different schools deal with such issues and what lessons can be garnered. I'd also like to have some representation from Council, either from the road safety or active travel teams, as they have a lot of knowledge and experience.
There's a couple of different issues bundled in here - encouraging more kids/parents to use active travel to get to school where appropriate but also making the streets around schools safer in general. We all know how quieter and safer the streets feel when the schools are on holiday, but it shouldn't be like that. I'd like to see them safer when the kids are on them, not when they're at home or in the park playing!
If you'd be interested in getting involved, or just attending a meeting to share ideas, please get in touch via comments, twitter, or email.
12 April 2013
Why people stop cycling...
View Larger Map
This is a lovely intersection that I go through most mornings. There are at least 3 primary schools in the vicinity, and myriads of nurseries. It's also a main throughfare between two much used parts of the off-road network. So lots of bikes, and as you can see, a pretty decent layout for cyclists wanting to cross at the Toucan crossing.
But, earlier this year a neighbour of mine was knocked off here by a supermarket delivery van turning left. My friend was going straight on like the royal mail van. (Oh, and he thought he was okay, but was later rushed into hospital for emergency surgery). Not nice.
And then this morning, as I coasted up the little ramp on the left, I saw a dad with a bright eyed toddler on the back nearly get left-hooked in exactly the same place by a blue Volkswagon that, just like the Tesco van, some how 'didn't see' the cyclist who had been coming straight down the hill for some distance.
This wasn't a cyclist who had just nipped into the car's near-side or anything else. The dad had been cycling safely and carefully along. The kid had give me a big wide-eyed look as they went by, clearly enjoying the ride. And it came so close to tragedy. Just because of inattention on the driver's part.
I really hope this dad doesn't stop cycling his wee boy to nursery, but I wouldn't blame him if he did.
Keep clear?
Yesterday there was a big scaffolding lorry completely blocking the space, stopped for an extended time, but with engine still running. Another mum on a bike came through just after me and commented that she was worried it was going to reverse into her. But a look at the cab showed the drivers were stopped for a fag and tea break.
Ironically, both vehicles are most likely connected to the construction work on the school, so found a nice 'safe' spot to keep out of the way until the kids were safely inside. But the keep clear being blocked means that all those parents who feel a compulsion to drive into the dead-end, so that they can drop their kids at the second gate then had to reverse back over the pedestrian crossing in front of the school. And their doing that then lead to other parents reversing back over the other pedestrian crossing. While hundreds of little kids were streaming across and into the school.
The thing is, if the parents 'learned' that they couldn't expect to turn at the bottom of the road, maybe they would stop driving in there? Because actually, they're much more of a menace to the kids and parents at the school than these vehicles are 'parked'.
And that's the real irony. Police and traffic wardens would be happy to ticket these vehicles for being illegally stopped, but my efforts to get some back up which would discourage parents from driving in front of the school have simply led to platitudes in the school newsletter and some clever banners on the railings, with no discernible effect.
07 April 2013
Not much has changed...everything has changed.
Two and a half years ago, Edinburgh launched its Active Travel Action Plan. In many ways, it's not a bad plan. But it hasn't aged well, and the current review process is showing this up all too clearly.
First, nothing much has changed. Of the things that I really wanted to see implemented via ATAP, very few have even begun. Some of these are really small interventions like public bike counters (or just publishing the data that exists!), removing 'guard' railings, cycle contraflows on one-way streets, and tackling footway parking. Others where we have seen incremental change include a piloted 20 mph zones (which leaves out all the big roads) and better cycle parking (but not in the city centre!).
However, the star attraction of ATAP (or drawback for some), was the plan for a 'family network' (see map on page 23 of this pdf). This approach comes in for a lot of criticism for directing cyclists along quiet roads, without doing anything much to improve the big roads that we all need to use to get to school, work and shopping. I'm not convinced that this is an entirely fair criticism of Edinburgh's plan. Our family network has the potential to be a lot more than that. Because we already have the extensive off-road network, the network was proposed to link up various bits of the city. Right now, from where I live in south-west Edinburgh, near the canal, we can cycle to the beach at Cramond, or the Botanics, or Leith, or out to Musselburgh and go most of the way on lovely, well-maintained off-road paths. But the remaining 10% of our journey is on scary, fast, poorly designed roads.
A few weeks ago, we had a lovely family cycle to Cramond. When we got there, we ran into a lot of people who live around us. They had all driven there so that their kids could cycle up and down the promenade. Ironically, we'd probably gotten there faster - or certainly not much slower. But they didn't feel that they could put their kids on the road even for that short section.
The Family Network is supposed to link all those bits up, so that you can go across town with your kids - faster than the buses - and not feel like a bad parent for risking their lives. On page 22 of this pdf you can read a list of the connecting bits that are prioritized for rapid completion. One of these has been done - an off-road connector between Leith and Portobello. By all accounts it is a fantastic addition, and already encouraging new cyclists to start cycling regularly.
But none of the rest has been done. And my concern is that plans for those mainly involve paint on roads, and that simply isn't going to get the South Edinburgh equivalent of the busy Mum who now cycles from Leith to work in Portobello on her bike, and certainly not if she has her kids in tow.
To look at just one example: the link from the Union Canal to the Russell Road access for the North Edinburgh Path Network. To anyone who knows this route, it is the most obvious, amazing access from South Edinburgh to the North (on the link above chose 'fastest route'). The Council's take on it is that there is an expensive off-road option that involves old railway infrastructure, OR a cheap on road access. And, if you look carefully at the on-road access (very hard to see because the map is so tiny), it appears to take you on a twisty route through the car parks of various housing estates, Dundee Terrace, and then down the Telfer subway to the Dalry Road. This is a massive diversion, and no real improvement if it just means paint on roads. I dare you to find a parent who currently doesn't let their kids cycle on the road, who says this would make the slightest difference to them.
When I asked why not just make the direct route safer for cyclists, I was told 'we'd have to take road-space away from cars'.
There you have it folks. Why Edinburgh's Family Network and Active Travel Action Plan - as presently being implemented - will never make more than incremental change to the number of cyclists on our streets.
We can have off-road cyclepaths -- where developments permit, or old infrastructure can be amended -- and on-road paint and signs, but we won't redesign roads so as to take roadspace away from cars.
This is where we come to what has changed since ATAP was launched. Not in Edinburgh, but everywhere else. In London, Chicago, New York, even Detroit, roadspace is being re-allocated away from cars to bikes, with spectacular results for local businesses and communities. Edinburgh needs to realize that while their plans are still stuck in the past, the environment has moved on.
First, nothing much has changed. Of the things that I really wanted to see implemented via ATAP, very few have even begun. Some of these are really small interventions like public bike counters (or just publishing the data that exists!), removing 'guard' railings, cycle contraflows on one-way streets, and tackling footway parking. Others where we have seen incremental change include a piloted 20 mph zones (which leaves out all the big roads) and better cycle parking (but not in the city centre!).
However, the star attraction of ATAP (or drawback for some), was the plan for a 'family network' (see map on page 23 of this pdf). This approach comes in for a lot of criticism for directing cyclists along quiet roads, without doing anything much to improve the big roads that we all need to use to get to school, work and shopping. I'm not convinced that this is an entirely fair criticism of Edinburgh's plan. Our family network has the potential to be a lot more than that. Because we already have the extensive off-road network, the network was proposed to link up various bits of the city. Right now, from where I live in south-west Edinburgh, near the canal, we can cycle to the beach at Cramond, or the Botanics, or Leith, or out to Musselburgh and go most of the way on lovely, well-maintained off-road paths. But the remaining 10% of our journey is on scary, fast, poorly designed roads.
A few weeks ago, we had a lovely family cycle to Cramond. When we got there, we ran into a lot of people who live around us. They had all driven there so that their kids could cycle up and down the promenade. Ironically, we'd probably gotten there faster - or certainly not much slower. But they didn't feel that they could put their kids on the road even for that short section.
The Family Network is supposed to link all those bits up, so that you can go across town with your kids - faster than the buses - and not feel like a bad parent for risking their lives. On page 22 of this pdf you can read a list of the connecting bits that are prioritized for rapid completion. One of these has been done - an off-road connector between Leith and Portobello. By all accounts it is a fantastic addition, and already encouraging new cyclists to start cycling regularly.
But none of the rest has been done. And my concern is that plans for those mainly involve paint on roads, and that simply isn't going to get the South Edinburgh equivalent of the busy Mum who now cycles from Leith to work in Portobello on her bike, and certainly not if she has her kids in tow.
To look at just one example: the link from the Union Canal to the Russell Road access for the North Edinburgh Path Network. To anyone who knows this route, it is the most obvious, amazing access from South Edinburgh to the North (on the link above chose 'fastest route'). The Council's take on it is that there is an expensive off-road option that involves old railway infrastructure, OR a cheap on road access. And, if you look carefully at the on-road access (very hard to see because the map is so tiny), it appears to take you on a twisty route through the car parks of various housing estates, Dundee Terrace, and then down the Telfer subway to the Dalry Road. This is a massive diversion, and no real improvement if it just means paint on roads. I dare you to find a parent who currently doesn't let their kids cycle on the road, who says this would make the slightest difference to them.
When I asked why not just make the direct route safer for cyclists, I was told 'we'd have to take road-space away from cars'.
There you have it folks. Why Edinburgh's Family Network and Active Travel Action Plan - as presently being implemented - will never make more than incremental change to the number of cyclists on our streets.
We can have off-road cyclepaths -- where developments permit, or old infrastructure can be amended -- and on-road paint and signs, but we won't redesign roads so as to take roadspace away from cars.
This is where we come to what has changed since ATAP was launched. Not in Edinburgh, but everywhere else. In London, Chicago, New York, even Detroit, roadspace is being re-allocated away from cars to bikes, with spectacular results for local businesses and communities. Edinburgh needs to realize that while their plans are still stuck in the past, the environment has moved on.
06 April 2013
A Cycling High Heid Yin?
I was sent this picture earlier today. It's a salutary reminder of how far we have come. On Monday, Spokes is holding a public meeting about 'the future of local transport', and an MSP and a local councillor are speaking. The MSP is co-convenor of the newly created Cross-party group on cycling, while the Councillor is deputy transport convenor, with a specific responsibility for cycling. It's a long way from local government with no real interest in or commitment to cycling, that led Spokes to cancel their 1980 meeting.
But despite all the remarkable changes -- most visible to many of us in the gritting of cycle paths this winter -- one conversation keeps recurring in different contexts. And that's people saying - where's the blockage? Is it the officials or the politicians?
Because somehow, despite the budget commitments, the explicit commitment by many Councillors, the good-natured cycling officers, the transport forum, a much lauded Active Travel Action Plan (ATAP), not much has really changed for cycling in Edinburgh in the 5 or so years that I've been back on the road (I was too scared to cycle here when we first moved here, despite having cycled in Canada, England and Zimbabwe).
The launch of the ATAP more or less coincided with my first foray into cycle campaigning - at a Spokes meeting, where I suggested that maybe cyclelanes with parking bays painted on top of them shouldn't be counted in our grand total of 'x number of miles of cycle lanes'. This seemed radical then, but I'm not sure it was, nor that it should have been. When I pursued the issue, the then transport convenor told me that it was no longer council policy to put cycle lanes in where they could be parked on.
But where have we gone since? There are no on-road segregated paths.. There are no mandatory cycle-lanes (ie ones that cars must stay out of). Instead, we get the 'quality' bike corridor, where the painted lanes sometimes go around parking bays instead of straight through them.
I think this captures the issue that people are trying to get at, when they say 'where's the blockage? what is holding us back'? There are valid points made about budgets, about a shortage of manpower, and many other issues that explain the failure to implement more than a tiny fraction of ATAP so far.
But the bigger question is, why has our vision stayed so stagnant? Why are hesitant commitments to 'consider' cycle infrastructure only accomplished after great lobbying efforts? Why is cycling infrastructure still not integrated into all planning? It remains an after thought, a box-ticking exercise - despite all the good will at Council.
All this leads me to think that we need a cycling champion to overcome these roadblocks. To knock heads together. To change how we think about cycling and to connect up all the synergies. I'm not usually enamoured with this very English approach to policy-making, but if the alternative is wasting the enthusiasm and goodwill that is currently present, then I think we should consider it. I suppose we'd need to call it something more Scottish though - how about a Cycling High Heid Yin?
In the meantime, I'm very much looking forward to this week's Spokes meeting.
But despite all the remarkable changes -- most visible to many of us in the gritting of cycle paths this winter -- one conversation keeps recurring in different contexts. And that's people saying - where's the blockage? Is it the officials or the politicians?
Because somehow, despite the budget commitments, the explicit commitment by many Councillors, the good-natured cycling officers, the transport forum, a much lauded Active Travel Action Plan (ATAP), not much has really changed for cycling in Edinburgh in the 5 or so years that I've been back on the road (I was too scared to cycle here when we first moved here, despite having cycled in Canada, England and Zimbabwe).
The launch of the ATAP more or less coincided with my first foray into cycle campaigning - at a Spokes meeting, where I suggested that maybe cyclelanes with parking bays painted on top of them shouldn't be counted in our grand total of 'x number of miles of cycle lanes'. This seemed radical then, but I'm not sure it was, nor that it should have been. When I pursued the issue, the then transport convenor told me that it was no longer council policy to put cycle lanes in where they could be parked on.
But where have we gone since? There are no on-road segregated paths.. There are no mandatory cycle-lanes (ie ones that cars must stay out of). Instead, we get the 'quality' bike corridor, where the painted lanes sometimes go around parking bays instead of straight through them.
I think this captures the issue that people are trying to get at, when they say 'where's the blockage? what is holding us back'? There are valid points made about budgets, about a shortage of manpower, and many other issues that explain the failure to implement more than a tiny fraction of ATAP so far.
But the bigger question is, why has our vision stayed so stagnant? Why are hesitant commitments to 'consider' cycle infrastructure only accomplished after great lobbying efforts? Why is cycling infrastructure still not integrated into all planning? It remains an after thought, a box-ticking exercise - despite all the good will at Council.
All this leads me to think that we need a cycling champion to overcome these roadblocks. To knock heads together. To change how we think about cycling and to connect up all the synergies. I'm not usually enamoured with this very English approach to policy-making, but if the alternative is wasting the enthusiasm and goodwill that is currently present, then I think we should consider it. I suppose we'd need to call it something more Scottish though - how about a Cycling High Heid Yin?
In the meantime, I'm very much looking forward to this week's Spokes meeting.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






